首都医科大学学报 ›› 2023, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (2): 328-334.doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1006-7795.2023.02.022

• 临床研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

儿童生殖细胞瘤全脑放射治疗中自适应消除摆位累积误差新技术探讨

王天赋,李星月,马明旭,关大维,许海燕,宫瑾*   

  1. 首都医科大学附属北京天坛医院放射治疗科, 北京  100070
  • 收稿日期:2022-06-27 出版日期:2023-04-21 发布日期:2023-04-18
  • 通讯作者: 宫瑾 E-mail:tf13718096814@163.com

Discussion on new technologies for adaptive elimination of set-up accumulation errors in whole-brain radiotherapy for childhood germ cell tumor

Wang Tianfu, Li Xingyue,  Ma Mingxu, Guan Dawei, Xu Haiyan, Gong Jin*   

  1. Department of Radiotherapy, Beijing Tiantan Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing  100070, China
  • Received:2022-06-27 Online:2023-04-21 Published:2023-04-18

摘要: 目的  以影像引导放射治疗(image guided-radiotherapy, IGRT)为基础探讨儿童生殖细胞瘤全脑自适应放射治疗(以下简称放疗)(adaptive radio therapy,ART)可行性,为临床全脑ART提供依据。方法  回顾性研究首都医科大学附属北京天坛医院放射治疗科20例中枢神经系统生殖细胞肿瘤(germ cell tumors, GCTs)行全脑预防性照射的放疗患者。每例患者治疗前三次及后每周行一次锥形束电子计算机断层扫描(cone beam computed tomography,CBCT),共7次。记录整个治疗过程中左右(lateral, LAT)、进出(longitudinal, LNG)、升降(vertical, VRT)方向上的摆位误差值。原计划命名为Plan_A,将因摆位误差值产生新的治疗中心点(treatment center point,ISO)回归治疗计划系统,不改变射野权重、射野分布情况下进行体积剂量计算,用Plan Sum功能相加摆位累积误差产生新计划得到Plan_B。将摆位累积误差产生的新计划用Acuros XB算法重新快速优化后用Plan Sum功能相加得到Plan_C。对比Plan_A、Plan_B、Plan_C的靶区及危及器官(organ at risk, OAR)剂量变化并用Wilcoxon配对符号秩检验证统计学差异。结果  与Plan_A相比,Plan_B 均匀性指均匀性指数(homogeneity index, HI)95计划靶区(planning target volume, PTV)、 HI98 PTV为1.058 4~1.084 7。适形度指数(conformity index, CI)PTV为0.934 4。 临床靶区(clinical target volume, CTV)Dmin相对偏差为-7.22%,P值为0.000 7。OAR相对偏差为-0.1%~9.8%。与Plan_ A相比,Plan_ C的HI95 PTV、 HI98 PTV为1.056 9~1.078 8。CI PTV为0.936 5。CTV Dmin相对偏差为-1.69%,P值为0.545 9。OAR相对偏差为-0.15%~3.40%。结论  儿童生殖细胞瘤全脑放疗摆位累计误差对靶区及危及器官剂量差异有统计学意义,摆位累计误差导致靶区均匀性及适形度变差,CTV的Dmin 变化超过5%,OAR受量增高。ART再计划可以让靶区均匀性和适形度及危及器官受量接近原计划。同时Plan_B虽然存在相对偏差,但是危及器官的绝对剂量在合理范围内。

关键词: 儿童生殖细胞瘤, 全脑放射治疗, 摆位累积误差, 自适应放射治疗, 剂量偏差

Abstract: Objective  To investigate the feasibility of adaptive radio therapy (ART) based on image guided-radiotherapy (IGRT) for pediatric germ cell tumors and to provide a basis for clinical whole-brain ART. Methods  A retrospective study was performed for 20 patients with germ cell tumors (GCTs) of the central nervous system who underwent whole brain prophylactic radiotherapy. Each patient underwent cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) once a week for the first three and subsequent treatments for a total of 7 sessions. Record the positioning error values in the lateral (LAT),  longitudinal (LNG), and vertical (VRT) directions during the entire treatment process. The original plan was named Plan_A, and a new treatment center point (ISO) regression treatment plan system was generated due to the positioning error value, and the volume dose was calculated without changing the field weight and field distribution, and the Plan Sum function was used to add the cumulative positioning error to generate a new plan to obtain Plan_B. The new plan generated by the cumulative positioning error is quickly optimized by the Acuros XB algorithm and added to the Plan Sum function to obtain Plan_C. The target and organ at risk (OAR) dose changes of Plan_A, Plan_B and Plan_C were compared, and the statistical differences were verified by Wilcoxon's paired rank test. Results  Compared with Plan_A, Plan_B homogeneity index (HI) 95  planning target volume(PTV) and HI98 PTV were 1.058 4-1.084 7. Conformity index (CI) PTV was 0.934 4. CTV Dmin relative deviation was -7.22%, P=0.000 7. OAR relative deviation was -0.1%-9.8%. Compared with Plan_ A, HI95 PTV and HI98 PTV of Plan_ C were 1.056 9-1.078 8. CI PTV was 0.936 5. CTV Dmin relative deviation was -1.69%, P=0.545 9. OAR relative deviation was  -0.15%-3.40%. Conclusion  There were statistical differences in the cumulative positioning error of whole brain radiotherapy for childhood germ cell tumor on the dose of target area and endangered organs, and the cumulative positioning error led to the deterioration of target uniformity and conformity, the Dmin change of CTV exceeded 5%, and the OAR reception increased. ART rescheduling can bring target uniformity and conformity and the amount of hazardous organs closer to the original plan. At the same time Plan_B although there is a relative deviation, the absolute dose of the endangering organ is within a reasonable range.

Key words: pediatric germ cell tumor, whole brain radiotherapy, cumulative set-up error, adaptive radiotherapy, dose deviation

中图分类号: